This pecan pie with the correct, selfmade all-butter crust is simple to make and is made with out corn syrup and with solely just a little bit little little bit of bourbon, for a not-too-sweet, elementary Thanksgiving dessert.

I’m a fan of all sorts of pie, considerably all by means of the holidays, the place I at all times make a pumpkin pie and a curry turkey pot pie (aka the correct concern you can do with these Thanksgiving leftovers!), plus an apple pie (on account of you’ll be able to actually not have an excessive amount of pie all by means of Thanksgiving). However the one pie that’s totally obligatory in our residence, is pecan pie. It at all times hits the spot, considerably after you’ve let your meal settle and your candy tooth kicks in. This pecan pie begins with a flaky, buttery crust stuffed with toasted pecans, then stuffed with a simple, mapley-sweet (not too gooey) filling spiked with a wee little little little bit of bourbon. And higher nonetheless, there’s no corn syrup on this pecan pie. Over time and loads of experimenting, I’ve discovered the appropriate crust-to-filling ratio and wonderful diploma of sweetness that makes it the correct pecan pie recipe, and one which’s now my go-to 12 months after 12 months.

Why You’ll Love It

• This pecan pie recipe swaps out commonplace corn syrup for a extra flavorful, better-for-you combination of maple syrup and Lyle’s Golden Syrup and is the appropriate diploma of sweetness
• A contact of bourbon enhances the nice and cozy, buttery, maple flavors of the pie fantastically
• My easy, fail-proof, all-butter pie crust makes this pecan pie extra particular

GET THE THANKSGIVING PREP GUIDE: Get your FREE Thanksgiving plan, timeline, recipe, and menu inspiration, plus all the foundations & methods it’s worthwhile to tug off the correct Thanksgiving nonetheless. AND! FREE printable. 

What’s contained in the BEST Pecan Pie

I’ve tinkered with all types of various variations by means of the years. I’ve tried chopped nuts, full nuts, maple syrup as an alternative of sunshine or darkish corn syrup, quite a bit a lot much less sugar, par-baked, not par-baked, booze, or no booze. The file goes on. What I’ve discovered is that pecan pie filling might be cloyingly candy. Furthermore, it’s usually made with corn syrup which I’m not a fan of. That’s why I forgo the corn syrup and use a combination of Lyle’s Golden Syrup and darkish brown sugar.

Correct proper right here’s what you’ll ought to make this pecan pie:

• 1 9-inch all-butter pie dough—you’ll be able to halve the recipe to make one pie crust
• Butter—gives type and richness to the pecan pie filling
• Darkish brown sugar—it gives a deeper, toastier, extra caramelized molasses type than delicate brown
• Lyle’s Golden Syrup—this British cane syrup seems to be like honey and has the equal viscosity as each honey and corn syrup nonetheless is a wee bit quite a bit a lot much less dangerous for you. Uncover it in well-stocked grocery shops, at World Market (it’s often contained in the UK part of the world meals aisle), or you’ll be able to order it on-line. Alternatively, use a particular high-quality golden syrup, honey, or ¾ cup darkish brown sugar and ½ cup maple syrup (the darker the higher).
• Eggs—assist bind the pecan pie collectively
• Bourbon—you’ll be able to undoubtedly go away it out if that’s not your concern. No want to make use of an dear bourbon correct proper right here, nonetheless don’t use basically probably the most fairly priced every.
• Vanilla extract—in the event you omit the bourbon, use 3 teaspoons of vanilla as an alternative of two.
• Kosher salt—at all times, for type
• Pecan halves—use uncooked, unsalted pecans and toast them beforehand in order that the pecan type actually sings.
• Maldon Sea Salt—a sprinkle of this flaky salt is a pleasant distinction with the sweetness of the pie

Uncover your entire recipe with measurements beneath.

The best way by which to Make the BEST Pecan Pie

• Make your pie dough. Make your pie dough in the event you haven’t already. Wrap your dough disc in plastic wrap and refrigerate for on the very least half-hour (ideally in a single day), or as quite a bit as 3 days.
• When you’re able to roll your dough, take away it from the fridge to a evenly floured countertop. Use your fingers to make indentations alongside the pores and pores and skin circle of the pie disc before rolling (this helps forestall the sides from cracking). Pound the dough with the rolling pin to heat it barely because of it flattens and turns into extra pliable.
• In relation to rolling out the dough take into consideration unfurling a flag, not steamrolling it. First, roll all alongside the pores and pores and skin fringe of the pie dough to flatten it barely. Then, ranging from the middle of the dough, roll the dough, rotating it with each few swipes, till it reaches the dimensions you’re looking for, about 12 to 13 inches for a 9-inch pie dish. Bake it in a glass pie dish like this one or I really like this non-stick pie dish too.

Tip: To know the way giant a circle you want in your pie, invert a pie tin and set it evenly on the dough, and reduce a circle all through the tin about 2-3 inches higher than the tin’s edges.

• Merely chill. Place your crimped pie dough contained in the freezer for about 20 or half-hour before baking. This helps quiet down the gluten a bit extra and permits the dough to firm up, which furthermore will forestall the butter from melting as quickly because of it hits the oven.

For the Finest Pecan Pie, Bake it Twice

No tall pecan pie recipes have you ever ever ever bake your pie twice. Nevertheless it’s my private want. Par-baking your pie before filling affords you extra insurance coverage protection safety that your crust obtained’t be underbaked or get soggy. It furthermore prevents the edges of the pie from slumping.

Par-bake your dough. I found a mannequin new technique to do this that works like a entice. Fill an oven-safe cooking bag with 6 cups of dry beans, raw rice, or pie weights. Place the bagged beans contained in the semi-frozen, pie shell, then put them straight into the oven. When completed, elevate the bag of beans from the pie shell and save the beans contained in the bag for an additional baking day.

The Finest Temperature to Par-Bake a Pie Dough

Relying on how heaps time you probably can have and your private want, par-bake decrease and slower or higher and sooner. I’ve tried each strategies with success nonetheless are likely to make the most of the low and gradual methodology extra often.

• Low and gradual: 350°F for about 45 minutes.
• Greater and sooner: 400°F for quarter-hour, then take away your bagged beans or pie weights and return the crust to the oven for five minutes extra.

Tip: Pies might be par-baked as quite a bit as 2 days upfront, and wrapped rigorously and tightly with plastic wrap.

Put collectively Your Filling

• Roast your nuts. Go away the oven at 350°F, or in the event you par-baked at 400°F, cut back your oven temp to 350°F. Place the pecan halves on a sheet pan and roast for 10 minutes.
• Use golden syrup as an alternative of corn syrup. On this recipe, a wonderful top of the range golden syrup subs in for thicker corn syrup. I reap the advantages of Lyle’s Golden Syrup, a British import with a deeper toasted type than heavy corn syrup. A wonderful top of the range golden syrup might be substituted. Alternatively, use an equal quantity of honey. Or, use ¾ cup darkish brown sugar and ½ cup maple syrup (the darker the higher).
• Whisk all of it collectively. In an unlimited bowl, mix your eggs, darkish brown sugar, golden syrup, bourbon, vanilla, and salt, and whisk appropriately to mix. Step-by-step whisk contained in the melted butter so that you just don’t scramble your eggs.

Assemble the Pecan Pie

• Put collectively the pecans on the underside of the pie shell and pour your filling overtop. Some folks chop their nuts into smaller objects nonetheless I like a heartier crunch. Inside the event you do chop, acquire this roughly for various sizes of nutty chunks.
• Add a layer of uncooked nuts to the perfect for a flowery look. Plan on spherical 1 cup of additional nuts to create a spiral prime. Use uncooked pecans for this step, not toasted, because of the nuts will roast as they sit on prime of the pie. Or, skip the presentation and go rustic.
• Bake your pie at 350°F for about 30-40 minutes. You’ll know the pie is accomplished when the crust is golden brown and the pie is about. It ought to nonetheless jiggle solely a bit whenever you give it a lightweight nudge. Let it cool and set for an hour before you slice and serve.

FAQ

• Is it bigger to make the most of delicate or darkish Karo syrup for pecan pie? Whereas pecan pies are historically made with corn syrup, I would like making mine with Lyle’s Golden Syrup and maple syrup on account of they’ve an exceedingly bigger type and mustn’t terribly processed. The Lyle’s is an excellent sub for corn syrup on account of it has primarily the equal viscosity to assist thicken your pecan pie filling.
• Ought to pecan pie be jiggly out of the oven? Constructive. The perfect of the pie ought to have overvalued some and be totally set, nonetheless nonetheless have just a little bit little little bit of jiggle contained in the coronary coronary heart whenever you gently give it a shake.
• Why does my pecan pie come out runny? This pecan pie shouldn’t be runny in the least (most runny pies are a outcomes of under-baking). Nevertheless, in order for you extra insurance coverage protection safety or a great thicker filling, add ½ cup extra nuts and/or 1 tablespoon of flour or cornstarch to your filling. Merely whisk it in with the eggs before you add the choice elements.

Ideas for Baking Pecan Pie

• Par-baking is your pal. Par-baking your pie crust before collectively together with your filling isn’t required, nonetheless I promise it makes an infinite distinction correct proper right here. Nobody likes an underbaked crust, and baking it twice will guarantee a pleasant, crisp crust with no soggy backside. Merely make sure you let it cool completely after par-baking and before filling (in one other case you would possibly get some leakage).
• Defend the pie if the nuts or crust begin to brown an excessive amount of. If it’s browning an excessive amount of, defend the sides from the warmth with strips of foil tented gently over the sides, or use a pie defend.
• Serve with whipped cream. There’s nothing bigger than selfmade whipped cream to go together with your pecan pie. I like sweetening mine up with only a bit maple syrup and a tiny pinch of salt—it’s SO good.

Storage

Due to pecan pie has eggs in it, it’s advisable that you just merely retailer it contained in the fridge to maintain up it newest and steer clear of any micro organism progress (and it’ll shield longer if saved contained in the fridge). That talked about, I at all times retailer (and serve) mine at room temperature and have actually not had any elements. It furthermore freezes fantastically (see beneath).

The best way by which to Freeze Pecan Pie

Due to it has a decrease water content material materials supplies than fruit pies, pecan pie lends itself appropriately to freezing. Bake your pie and let it cool completely (for an hour or so). Then, wrap it rigorously and utterly with plastic wrap or foil (to stop freezer burn) and place it in a zippered freezer bag. Retailer it contained in the freezer for as much as some weeks then defrost it contained in the fridge in a single day.

To reheat your pie from frozen, let it sit on the counter for a couple of minutes after which cowl it loosely with foil. (The foil will forestall the crust from burning.) Place it on a sheet pan and bake in a 350°F oven for about 15-20 minutes.

Completely completely different Pie Recipes You’ll Love

Inside the event you make this recipe, please let me know! Go away a ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ ranking on this recipe beneath and go away a remark, take {{a photograph}} and tag me on Instagram with #foodiecrusheats.